I liked it ... it was decent ... but it could have been better (can anybody scream the release of Lord of the Rings, yet?). The effects were surprisingly good, but it just seemed to me that the editing, storyline and performances just didn't know whether to be a big budget blockbuster, or cheap B movie. I wanted to dislike the decision to use Justin Whalin as lead character, Ridley Freeborn the thief (he played the teen Andy in Child's Play 3) ... but on more than one occasion he would surprise me with an above-average deliverance of lines in a scene. Would I have preferred the use of Warrior or Ranger for the lead? Hell, yes, but that's cause I just never liked thieves, of any kind.